[Classic] #47. Niccolò Machiavelli’s “The Prince”

Niccolò Machiavelli’s “The Prince” is a 16th-century political treatise emphasizing the need for a strong ruler amidst Italy’s turmoil. Machiavelli presents a realistic perspective, separating politics from morality. He views humans as selfish and fickle, advocating for rule through fear and punishment. The Prince should adapt virtues and vices according to circumstances, highlighting the role of fate and choice in governance.

Author Introduction

Niccolò Machiavelli (1469–1527) was an Italian diplomat, philosopher, and writer, often regarded as the father of modern political science. Born into a middle-class family in Florence, he entered public service as a young man and quickly rose to become a prominent official in the Florentine Republic. Serving as a diplomat, he witnessed the turbulent politics of Renaissance Italy, marked by the constant struggle for power among city-states and the influence of foreign powers such as France and Spain. In 1512, the Medici family regained control of Florence, and Machiavelli was dismissed from his post and briefly imprisoned. During his subsequent exile in the Tuscan countryside, he wrote “The Prince,” dedicating it to Lorenzo de’ Medici in the hope of regaining political favor​​.

Historical Context

Division and Turmoil in Italy

During the late 15th and early 16th centuries, Italy was not a unified nation but a collection of city-states such as Florence, Venice, and Milan, as well as the Papal States and the Kingdom of Naples. These states were often at war with each other and vulnerable to external invasion by France, Spain, and the Holy Roman Empire. This period of political fragmentation and foreign dominance influenced Machiavelli’s thoughts on the necessity of a strong and cunning ruler capable of unifying and protecting Italy.

Summary of “The Prince”

“The Prince” consists of 26 chapters, written as a practical guide for ruling and maintaining power, rather than a philosophical treatise on ideal governance. Machiavelli’s pragmatic approach to political power emphasizes realpolitik, often divorced from traditional moral and ethical considerations​​.

Chapter 1: The Types of Principalities and Their Acquisition

Machiavelli begins by categorizing principalities into hereditary (inherited) and new (acquired) states. Hereditary principalities are easier to govern due to established traditions and loyalty, while new principalities present more challenges due to the need to establish new governance structures​​.

Chapter 2: Hereditary Principalities

Hereditary rulers have the advantage of tradition and established loyalty, making it easier to maintain power. As long as they do not cause widespread dissatisfaction, they can rule effectively by preserving the status quo​​.

Chapter 3: Mixed Principalities

Newly acquired territories, or mixed principalities, face significant challenges in governance. Machiavelli advises rulers to either reside in the new territory, establish colonies, or maintain a strong military presence to prevent rebellion and ensure loyalty​​.

Chapter 4: Why the Kingdom of Darius, Conquered by Alexander, Did Not Rebel Against His Successors

Machiavelli contrasts two types of governance: one where the ruler governs directly with appointed ministers (such as the Ottoman Empire) and another where the ruler governs through hereditary nobles (like France). Direct governance is more centralized and easier to control but harder to conquer. Once conquered, it is easier to maintain as there are fewer power centers to resist​​.

Chapter 5: How to Govern Cities or Principalities That Lived Under Their Own Laws

To maintain control over a conquered state that previously had its own laws and freedoms, a ruler must either destroy it, reside there, or allow it to maintain its laws but impose a tributary system. Destroying the state ensures it cannot rebel, while residing there or granting limited autonomy can secure loyalty​​.

Chapter 6: Concerning New Principalities Acquired by One’s Own Arms and Ability

Princes who acquire power through their own abilities, rather than fortune, are more likely to succeed. These rulers can create new states and establish strong foundations, as their success is based on merit and effective governance​​.

Chapter 7: Concerning New Principalities Acquired with the Arms and Fortunes of Others

Princes who rise to power through the help of others or through fortune often struggle to maintain their rule. Such rulers lack the foundational support and experience necessary to sustain their governance and are vulnerable to losing power when circumstances change​​.

Chapter 8: Concerning Those Who Have Achieved Sovereignty by Wickedness

Machiavelli discusses rulers who come to power through nefarious means, such as murder or treachery. While these methods can be effective, they require the ruler to maintain strict control and instill fear to prevent rebellion​​.

Chapter 9: Concerning a Civil Principality

A civil principality arises when a private citizen gains power with the support of fellow citizens. Such rulers must balance the interests of the elite and the general populace to maintain stability and avoid conflict​​.

Chapter 10: How the Strength of All Principalities Should Be Measured

Machiavelli advises rulers to assess their military strength and their ability to defend against internal and external threats. A self-sufficient military is crucial for maintaining power and independence​​.

Chapter 11: Concerning Ecclesiastical Principalities

Ecclesiastical principalities, governed by religious leaders, are unique in that they are sustained by longstanding religious institutions and beliefs. These states require less effort to maintain as their foundation lies in faith and tradition​​.

Chapter 12: The Different Kinds of Military Forces

Machiavelli warns against relying on mercenaries and auxiliary troops, as they are often unreliable and self-interested. Instead, he advocates for a standing army composed of loyal and well-trained citizens​​.

Chapter 13: Concerning Auxiliary, Mixed, and Native Forces

Native forces, composed of the ruler’s own subjects, are the most reliable. Auxiliary forces, borrowed from allies, can be dangerous as their loyalty lies elsewhere. Mercenaries are motivated by profit and can be treacherous​​.

Chapter 14: A Prince’s Duty Concerning Military Matters

A prince must prioritize military readiness, constantly studying the art of war and preparing for conflict. Historical examples of successful rulers demonstrate the importance of military expertise and vigilance​​.

Chapter 15: Concerning Things for Which Men, and Especially Princes, Are Praised or Blamed

Machiavelli discusses the qualities that earn praise or blame, arguing that a prince should not shy away from being feared or acting immorally if it ensures the stability and security of the state​​.

Chapter 16: Concerning Liberality and Meanness

A prince should avoid excessive generosity, which can lead to financial ruin and necessitate heavy taxation. Instead, he should be frugal, using resources wisely to maintain the state and avoid burdening his subjects​​.

Chapter 17: Concerning Cruelty and Clemency, and Whether It Is Better to Be Loved Than Feared

Machiavelli argues that it is better for a prince to be feared than loved if he cannot be both. Fear ensures obedience, while love can be fickle and unreliable. However, a prince should avoid being hated, as it can lead to rebellion​​.

Chapter 18: Concerning the Way in Which Princes Should Keep Faith

Princes should be willing to break promises and deceive if it benefits the state. The successful ruler must balance the cunning of a fox with the strength of a lion, using both deceit and force to maintain power​​.

Chapter 19: Concerning Avoiding Contempt and Hatred

A prince must avoid actions that generate hatred and contempt among his subjects. He should respect property and personal honor, and avoid unnecessary cruelty to maintain the loyalty and support of the people​​.

Chapter 20: Concerning Fortresses and Other Defensive Measures

The use of fortresses and other defensive measures depends on the prince’s circumstances. Fortresses can be beneficial in some cases but can also create a false sense of security and alienate the people​​.

Chapter 21: How a Prince Should Conduct Himself to Gain Renown

A prince should engage in grand public works, demonstrate his virtues, and align himself with powerful allies to gain respect and renown. He should also avoid neutrality in conflicts, as decisiveness earns admiration​​.

Chapter 22: Concerning the Prince’s Ministers

The selection of capable and loyal ministers is crucial for effective governance. A prince should choose advisors who prioritize the state’s interests over personal gain and ensure they remain dependent on his favor​​.

Chapter 23: How Flatterers Should Be Avoided

A prince must guard against flatterers by allowing a few trusted advisors to speak honestly. He should create an environment where truth is valued and dissent is not punished, fostering wise counsel and sound decision-making​​.

Chapter 24: Why the Princes of Italy Have Lost Their States

Machiavelli analyzes the failures of Italian princes, attributing their losses to weak military defenses and the inability to maintain the support of their subjects. He emphasizes the need for strong leadership and military prowess​​.

Chapter 25: Concerning Fortune, and How She Should Be Accepted

Machiavelli posits that fortune controls half of human actions, while the other half is determined by free will. A prudent prince must adapt to changing circumstances and seize opportunities to shape his destiny​​.

Chapter 26: An Exhortation to Free Italy from the Barbarians

In the final chapter, Machiavelli calls for a strong and unifying leader to liberate Italy from foreign domination. He urges the Medici family to take up this mantle and restore Italy to its former glory​​.

답글 남기기

이메일 주소는 공개되지 않습니다. 필수 필드는 *로 표시됩니다